Today, with the increasing development of online shopping and logistics, we always hope that our beloved babies will be intact when delivered to our hands. So, as a "personal bodyguard" to protect goods, who is more trustworthy, bubble bags or honeycomb paper bags? In order to find the answer, we specially conducted two small competitions - drop shock resistance PK and load-bearing capacity PK to see their respective "real skills"!

1. First impression:

Bubble bags are made of plastic and contain many small inflated bubbles inside, making them lightweight and soft. The honeycomb paper bag is made of kraft paper and has a unique honeycomb structure design inside, giving it a certain strength and elasticity. Both have their own characteristics, but who is better at protecting goods?

2. Drop and earthquake resistance PK:

First, we conducted a "drop and earthquake resistance competition" to simulate a drop scenario during express logistics handling. The bubble bag and honeycomb paper bag containing glass cups were freely dropped from the same height and repeated many times. What was the result?

3. Load-bearing capacity PK

Secondly, we conducted a "load-bearing capacity competition", placing heavy objects (about 6 kilograms) on bubble bags and honeycomb paper bags respectively for 10 minutes and then taking them away to observe their compression range and rebound degree. What is the result?

2.7cm before start                  1cm after compression                        1cm after compression

● Bubble bag: initial height 2.7 cm, height after compression 1 cm, height after rebound 2.5cm. Under pressure, the thickness of the bubble bag is significantly reduced, showing strong compressibility and buffering force, effectively dispersing pressure. After the book is removed, the bubble bag returns to its original shape, showing excellent elasticity.

2.8cm before start                       2.3cm after compression                     2.7cm after rebound

● Honeycomb paper bag: starting height is 2.8cm, height after compression is 2.3cm, and height after rebound is 2.7cm. In the face of pressure, the thickness of honeycomb paper bags changes little, showing good compression resistance. Its stable structure allows it to return to its original shape after being subjected to stress.

4. PK conclusion

Through the above PK, we draw the following conclusions:

Generally speaking, bubble bags are suitable for fragile items that may be impacted during short-term transportation, while honeycomb paper bags are more suitable for packaging that carries heavy loads or requires high compression resistance.

5. Comprehensive consideration

In addition to PK results, we also need to consider factors such as cost, environmental protection, and application scenarios.

● Cost: Bubble bags are low-cost and suitable for large-volume use; honeycomb paper bags are relatively high-end and suitable for products with high packaging requirements.

● Waterproof: Bubble bags usually have good waterproof performance due to the characteristics of their own materials and internal bubble structures; honeycomb paper bags themselves are not waterproof, but they can be improved through special processes.

● Environmental protection: There are already degradable bubble bags on the market, such as XCGS fully degradable kraft paper bubble bags; all honeycomb paper bags are made of pure kraft paper, which is environmentally friendly and fully degradable, in line with the current environmental protection trend.

● Application scenarios: Bubble bags are lightweight, easy to carry, waterproof and wear-resistant, and are suitable for packaging small items; honeycomb paper bags, due to their strong carrying capacity, are suitable for heavy objects or situations that require high pressure and strong support.

To sum up, bubble bags and honeycomb paper bags have their own advantages, and there is no absolute winner. Which packaging material to choose should be comprehensively decided based on actual needs, cost considerations and environmental protection requirements. If you are looking for cost-effectiveness and waterproofness, bubble bags will be a good choice; and if you pay more attention to environmental protection or need to package heavy goods, honeycomb paper bags are the best choice. At the same time, by adding honeycomb paper and optimizing the honeycomb structure, the protective performance of honeycomb paper bags can be further improved to meet more diversified packaging needs. XCGS Group can provide you with professional packaging solution consultation to ensure that your baby is protected with the utmost peace of mind!